One of the most important investments that parents will make is purchasing a mattress for their baby.
The best crib mattress will ensure your little one spends the first couple of years in the most comfortable sleeping environment.
As babies spend most of their time in a crib, the mattress must support their delicate head and neck.
To help you make a smart choice for your infant, we’ve combed the internet and found the most praised products. Here’s a list of the best crib mattresses you can consider.
Comparison Chart
Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Mattress in a Box – GREENGUARD Gold Certified, Non-Toxic, Breathable, Removable Washable Water Resistant Outer Cover
Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed – 100% Breathable Proven to Reduce Suffocation Risk, 100% Washable, 2-Stage, Hypoallergenic Non-Toxic Better Than Organic, Removable Cover Included- White
Milliard Premium Memory Foam Hypoallergenic Infant Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed Mattress with Waterproof Bamboo Cover, Flip Dual Stage System – 27.5 inches x 52 inches x 5.5 inches
Eco Classica III 2-Stage Baby & Toddler Mattress by Colgate Mattress | Organic Waterproof Cotton Cover | Hypoallergenic | Eco-Friendly Foam | GREENGUARD Gold Certified
Best Crib Mattresses Reviews
Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Mattress
Unlike other mattresses on the market, the Graco Premium model is incredibly affordable. This can immediately be a red flag for many parents. Is it too good to be true that a mattress can be both safe for your baby and so affordable?
Fortunately, this product combines both price and functionality, which is why it’s a great option for those on a tight budget.
Review
This mattress is made from polyethylene foam, often used for baby mattresses. When you first get the product, you’ll notice it’s compressed. Once you unpack it, you must wait for at least 48h to decompress before you can put it in a crib, so keep that in mind.
Since it’s advertised as a mattress for babies and toddlers, some parents might worry about how firm it is.
However, this product is firm enough to support gentle heads, and build strong muscles, but doesn’t create too much bounce. Moreover, it’s soft enough so that your child can sleep comfortably.
The mattress is made of high-quality breathable materials and doesn’t contain phthalates, which can contribute to sudden infant death syndrome.
The foam is water-repellent. Although this is not as good as a water-resistant mattress, it’ll still keep your baby dry.
The best crib mattresses feature anti-static and anti-microbial materials, which are gentle for your baby’s skin, and this model is no exception. Furthermore, it meets fire regulations standards, and it also comes with a fireproof cover.
Size-wise, the Graco mattress is 52 inches long, 27.6 inches wide, and 5 inches high.
Pros
- Affordable
- Suitable for babies and toddlers
- Water-resistant
- Recommended firmness
Cons
- Long decompression time
- No organic materials
Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed
Newton is a household name in the baby mattress industry. Despite being the most expensive model on our list, the Newton baby mattress is worth the cost. It combines functionality and design.
Review
One feature that separates the Newton baby mattress from other models is the unique Wovenaire technology. In a nutshell, the core of the mattress is made from a food-grade polymer combined with water. The result is cushioning, which is 90% air and 10% other materials.
Moreover, all materials are toxin and chemical-free, as regulated by the Greenguard Gold. And when you’re looking for the best crib mattress, it better to be as safe as you can.
Breathability is one of the most important aspects of a crib mattress. Your little one tends to roll and move throughout the night, which is why they sometimes sweat.
For this reason, a baby’s mattress needs to be lightweight and breathable, so that your baby can sleep comfortably. Plus, this gives you peace of mind, knowing your baby will be safe and dry. The Newton baby mattress provides all of this.
Another thing we love about the Newton crib mattress is how you can wash the outside cover, as well as the inside. As your child starts growing, there will be more mess.
Diaper blowouts and accidental milk or juice spills can happen often. That’s why it’s good to have a mattress you can easily wash.
When you buy the product, you’ll get instructions regarding how to wash it. What’s more, since the mattress is hypoallergenic, you don’t have to worry about bacteria.
Finally, the mattress measures 52 inches by 28 inches by 5 inches.
Pros
- Hypoallergenic
- Fully washable
- Patented Wovenaire technology
- Breathable
Cons
- Expensive
- Unpleasant initial smell
Milliard Premium Memory Foam Hypoallergenic Infant Crib Mattress
If you’re looking for a crib mattress that combines price with functionality, then this one from Milliard is a great choice. It’s among the most affordable baby mattresses on the market but boasts features that only organic crib mattresses usually have, such as high-density foam and a pain-relieving design.
Review
First, as this mattress weighs only 8 pounds, it’s incredibly lightweight. Therefore, lifting it to change the sheets won’t be an issue.
Mattresses should be made of high-density foam, and fortunately, Milliard is one of the best. The premium foam used in their manufacturing ensures the child’s development and provides support while sleeping.
Besides, the foam in a Milliard mattress isn’t too firm, so it shouldn’t be uncomfortable for your toddler.
The memory foam also relieves any muscle or joint pain your baby might experience, as they try to find a comfortable position. Since they can sleep well throughout the night, there is much less tossing around.
Another thing we love is the in-built air-flow features. This means that if it becomes too hot in the room, and your child overheats, the channels in the mattress will let out some of the cool air. This unique technology ensures your baby is dry and sleeps well throughout the night.
A lot of parents have sensed a strange smell from the mattress. The smell comes from the packing and although it tends to dissipate after a while, it may be an initial problem for some.
It won’t cause any issues to your child, but those who are in general sensitive to smell may not like it. As long as you follow the instructions for airing out the mattress, you shouldn’t have any problems.
The mattress measures 52 inches by 27.5 inches by 5.5 inches, but you can’t customize the size.
Pros
- Air-flow technology
- High-density foam
- Lightweight
- Affordable
Cons
- Tends to smell bad
- Size not customized
Eco Classica III 2-Stage Baby
Are you looking for a mattress that has a firm side suitable for babies and a softer one perfect for toddlers? Well, this Eco classical crib mattress is just that. Size-wise, it’s 51.75 inches by 27.5 inches by 6 inches, which is pretty standard.
Review
Since this is a dual-side mattress, it’s suitable for your baby, but it’ll also serve them as they become toddlers. The firm side is hard enough and doesn’t show signs of indention even after months of use.
The side for toddlers is much softer, just as it should be. There’s also a tag that shows which side is which. That way, you won’t have issues placing the wrong side up in the crib.
This mattress is made of organic materials. The cotton used in the manufacturing process has not been treated with pesticides or insecticides. This gives parents peace of mind knowing that only safe materials are close to their baby’s skin.
Plus, the waterproof materials support the cover, so you don’t have to worry about your little one being wet during the night.
Manufacturers often use damaging petroleum-based oils for the inside of the mattress.
However, Eco Classica doesn’t. Since the insides of their mattresses are made of plant oils, even eco-friendly parents will be thrilled with this mattress. The only problem is that you can’t remove the cover of the mattress, which can be a problem when you need to clean it.
Pros
- Organic materials
- Waterproof
- Eco-friendly
- Doesn’t contain petroleum-based oils
Cons
Cover not removable
Dream On Me, Holly 3” Fiber Portable Crib Mattress
We’ve also found an option for parents on a tight budget. This inexpensive crib mattress costs less than $30. But doesn’t mean it’s made of poor-quality materials. The inside is made from an eco-fiber that creates a comfortable environment for your baby.
Review
Although inexpensive, the mattress is made of hypoallergenic and antibacterial materials. Plus, the cover helps prevent any odor that comes from diaper blowouts.
For families who live in a smaller house and don’t have much free space, this mattress is an excellent choice. It’s perfect for portable and mini cribs but it doesn’t fit the standard-sized cribs.
Since it’s so inexpensive, you might assume that the mattress is hard enough to provide the proper skeletal development. But the firmness level of the Dream On mattress is just right for a baby, to help them develop.
Some parents complain that the stitching isn’t of the best quality. They’ve had problems after their children have been using the mattress for a while. Furthermore, there have been issues of mold appearing. It seems that the mattress isn’t waterproof, which can cause mold.
Pros
- Inexpensive
- Cleans easily
- Antibacterial
- The right amount of firmness
Cons
- Poor-quality stitching
- Not waterproof
Final Verdict
When choosing a crib mattress, support and comfort are among the most important factors you should consider. But with a myriad of options out there, it can be overwhelming to choose the best crib mattress, especially when you’re expecting your first child.
A crib mattress that many parents love is the Newton baby crib mattress, which is why it’s our top choice. Although expensive, you can use it even when your baby becomes a toddler.
The patented Wovenaire technology it uses makes the cushioning almost 90% air. This feature allows your baby to breathe much better. Plus, you can easily wash the entire mattress in the washing machine and get it ready for your little one.
The runner up has to be the Graco premium mattress. Although not organic, the materials used in manufacturing are standard baby mattress materials. It’s also relatively affordable.